The following is a list of guides for getting the Good Endings/True Ending in Cemetery Mary. Please be aware that reading these guides will give you spoilers. Not all of the correct choices are needed to get a good ending, but you need ~70% of the correct choices to get a good ending. Aside from a few different scenes, the True Ending is the same regardless of the route that you achieved it on.

For Twyla’s Good Ending:

1. When meeting Twyla at the cafe, stay quiet all three times you are given the option.
2. When in front of the bookstore, tell Twyla that she has a point.
3. Do NOT become friends with the bookstore owner. The easiest way to do this is by spamming the first option until the bookstore scene is over.
4. Agree with Twyla that it was right to steal from the bookstore owner by saying “I suppose”.
5. Lie each time you are able to during Twyla’s interrogation scene.
6. When Twyla asks for your address, tell her you will be at the cemetery.
7. When caught by the nurse in the retirement home, do NOT call Twyla over.
8. Ask Ed how his wife died.
9. When Twyla talks about the antifreeze sample, simply ask “Analysis”?
10. When looking for antifreeze in the store, say that “It has to be here”.
11. Tell Twyla she has a good point when she suspects Reginald over the phone.
12. When deciding on a ghost to talk to, choose the girl.
13. Tell the mystery number that you think Twyla is a good person.
14. Go with Twyla to the hardware store.
15. Tell Reginald that you are building a birdhouse.
16. Tell Reginald you do not have experience with rodents.
17. Pretend to talk to ghosts during Twyla’s family dinner.
18. A broken column headstone represents life cut short.

For Reginald’s Good Ending:

1. When meeting Reginald, be honest about the kind of book that you want.
2. When shopping with Reginald, buy him ONLY the tools he asked for--no more and no less. The correct choices are antifreeze, an axe, rat poison, and measuring tape. 
3. Ask Reginald why he bought an axe at the cash register.
4. After the coffin incident, ask Reginald “Are you sure?” over the phone.
5. Call yourself Reginald’s girlfriend at the funeral service.
6. When Mary tells Reginald she’s feeling sick, ask to lie down at his place.
7. When Mary is feeling sick at home, tell Crowven it’s okay for him to leave.
8. When talking to the priest at church, ask if someone is trying to contact you.
9. When confronted by Twyla, ask her to “please don’t yell”.
10. When Mary runs into the alleyway, you need Reginald to show up with an umbrella. There are multiple answer choices that can accomplish this, but one way is by telling Reginald that it is your fault, but asking him to “please don’t” talk to Twyla about it.
11. When Reginald contacts you after the library scene, ask Reginald if he thinks you are weird.
12. During the restaurant scene, tell Reginald “I’ve always lived here”.
13. During the car scene, ask Reginald if he doesn’t like living in Blackwood.
14. When Reginald asks what your favorite part of the aquarium was, tell him that you liked either the manta ray or the puffer fish.
15. Say that being called Cemetery Mary is better than nothing.
16. Call Reginald your best friend.
17. When watching TV at Reginald’s place, tell Reginald that you want to watch the mystery, horror, or romantic comedy.

For Crowven’s Good Ending:

1. At the beginning of the game, go straight to bed instead of attempting conversation with Crowven at the fireplace.
2. You have to beat Crowven at the arcade machine. You can accomplish this by clicking the bottom option, top option, and bottom option in that order.
3. When meeting Crowven’s friends, tell them that you’ve heard great things about them.
4. When Crowven says he has a plan to get in the club, answer “If you say so.”
5. When in the bathroom, say that Crowven “doesn’t mean it”.
6. When meeting Twyla in the bathroom, decline her offer to go to the VIP area.
7. When Crowven asks if you were bothered by the “Scary Mary” comments, say yes.
8. Agree to go to the haunted house with Crowven’s friends.
9. When Reginald takes Mary out for coffee, attempt to walk away.
10. At Theo’s funeral, remain silent.
11. When talking to Theo, ask him “What do you remember happening before this?”
12. When confronted by Twyla, tell her that you “are not cut out for this”.
13. When speaking with Zapara in the cemetery, tell her that “Theo would’ve wanted her here”.
14. When talking with Crowven in his room, tell him “Everything sucks”.
15. When talking with Crowven in his room, tell him “How can I help?”
16. When talking with Crowven in his room, tell him “I want to help”.
17. When talking with Crowven in his room, tell him “It gets better”.
18. When choosing a friend to sleep over with, choose Reginald. Choosing Twyla may deduct points.

These next guides will tell you how to get the True Ending on each individual route. Please note that in order to see the True Ending, you MUST go through the good or bad ending of your respective route first. Once the end card has faded, you will know if you received the True Ending when the game does not say “Congratulations!", and continues on.

In the main script:

1. Ask the Mystery Number who they are the first time.
2. Ask the Mystery Number who they are the second time.
3. When you find a stranger in the diner, call the Mystery Number before calling anyone else.
4. When you are at the movie theater, call the Mystery Number before calling anyone else.

To get the True Ending in Twyla’s route:

1. Ask the Mystery Number to tell who they are.
2. Become friends with the bookstore owner. You can do this by telling the bookstore owner that you "Just wanted to say hi!"
3. When meeting Twyla’s Uncle, stay silent.
4. Do not pretend to be Ed’s granddaughter.
5. Tell the Mystery Number “There was an emergency” after the retirement home scene.
6. Ask the Mystery Number if they believe in ghosts.
7. Tell the Mystery Number “Good night”.
8. Ask the Mystery Number “And will I see you?”.

To get the True Ending in Reginald’s route:

1. When the Mystery Number says they shouldn’t talk about what they do, ask “Why not?”.
2. Ask the Mystery Number if they are trapped.
3. Tell the Mystery Number you are scared they will stop responding.
4. When the Mystery Number says to take care of yourself, say “I will”.
5. Ask the Mystery Number “Are you still coming for me?”.
6. Ask the Mystery Number if they were caught in the rain.
7. Ask the Mystery Number why they chose to come after you.
8. Ask the Mystery Number how you can trust someone like them.
9. Watch the murder mystery movie at Reginald’s.
10. If you’ve unlocked Reginald’s good ending, you must DUCK during the quick time event.

To get the True Ending in Crowven’s route:

1. Ask the Mystery Number “Who are you?”.
2. Ask the Mystery Number “Is it because you’re scared?”.
3. When arguing with Theo in the cemetery, say that “there’s families here!”.
4. Tell the Mystery Number that things have been harder than normal.
5. Ask the Mystery Number “Do you know who I’m with?”.
6. Ask the Mystery Number how they felt losing someone.
7. Ask the Mystery Number how they can make things better.
8. Watch the murder mystery movie whilst staying at Reginald’s.